Our Misguided Belief in the Impact of Our Recycling Efforts—But That's Okay

Key Points:

• Recycling rates have improved since the 1960s, but wish-cycling practices can lead to negative outcomes.
• Questions arise about the effectiveness of individual recycling in addressing climate change, given that 100 companies account for over 70% of greenhouse gas emissions.
• Engaging in recycling and environmental activism positively impacts mental health by promoting a sense of control and harmony with the environment.
• While individual efforts may not directly change the world, they can inspire collective action and encourage accountability among larger entities.

The Complexities of Recycling

Many engage in recycling without considering the potential consequences. Wish-cycling, the practice of placing items in the recycling bin without knowing if they're actually recyclable, can cause problems during the recycling process. This can result in unrecyclable items ending up in landfills or polluting the environment.

Recent years have witnessed the cancellation of recycling programs in certain cities due to challenges like the lack of markets for recycled materials and the high costs associated with recycling. Moreover, China, previously a major destination for recyclable materials, has ceased accepting most foreign recyclables.

Debating the Effectiveness of Recycling

Although the recycling rate has increased over time, there are doubts about its efficacy in addressing climate change. The Carbon Majors Report (2017) revealed that just 100 companies are responsible for over 70% of global greenhouse gas emissions. This raises concerns about whether individual recycling efforts can make a significant impact in combating climate change.

Mental Health Benefits of Recycling

Despite the challenges, recycling and other forms of individual environmental activism have positive effects on mental health. Studies demonstrate that being close to nature and engaging in ecotherapy can improve mental health and reduce stress.

Taking care of the planet through actions like recycling gives us a sense of control over our environment, helps us feel more connected to the world around us, and fosters a sense of peace and satisfaction.

Balancing Individual and Collective Action

While individual recycling efforts may not directly change the world, they can contribute to our mental well-being and inspire us to take further action. Recognizing that larger corporations and governments also have a significant role in addressing climate change, we can hold them accountable while still doing our part.

In essence, making an effort to recycle, even if it's not always effective, is better than inaction. Recycling aluminum cans is a good step, but we must do more to protect the environment and mitigate climate change.